id	summary	reporter	owner	description	type	status	priority	milestone	component	version	severity	resolution	keywords	cc
11477	Unable to Crop Images in RC1	miqrogroove		"There appear to be several bugs in the Image Crop input fields.  I'll let you decide which of these symptoms are valid.

1. Go to the Edit Media screen for an image.

2. Click & Drag to highlight an area of the image.

3. Enter an Aspect ratio of 4:3.  '''The image selection changes but the Selection fields are not updated.'''

4. Attempt to change the Aspect ratio to 4:7.  '''Input is erased as soon as I type it in.'''  This makes no sense at first, but appears to be some kind of boundary feedback?

5. Attempt to change the Aspect ratio to 10:11.  '''Input is impossible unless the second field is empty.'''

6. Change the Aspect ratio to 7:8 and then change it to 7.9:8.  '''Nothing happens.'''

7. In common graphics vocabulary, ""Selection"" always refers to a pair of rectangular coordinates.  '''Using the word ""Selection"" where ""Size"" is what you meant''' to say is confusing.

8. Scale Image is collapsed by default, with no indiciation that it can be expanded except for a slight difference in text color, and the cursor changes on mouse over.  This is inconsistent with the Image Crop area, which is '''not collapsible'''.

9. There is '''no way to enter a decimal coefficient''' for the Aspect ratio.  Even 1.67:1 doesn't work.  Unless the user wants to always use 1:1, 16:9, 8:5, 5:4, or 4:3, the existing Aspect Ratio fields will be useless.  The interface would make more sense with a limited set of radio options.

10. '''The original image Aspect Ratio is not displayed.'''  If my image has an Aspect of 1.39847, and I want to ""lock it in"" while cropping, there is no obvious way to do it.

11. '''The new image Aspect Ratio is not displayed.'''  If I crop by click & drag, or by typing in the Selection fields, there is no way to know the resulting Aspect Ratio without pulling out a calculator.

12. The original image '''dimensions are not displayed''', unless the Scale Image area has been expanded.  Cropping is just that much more awkward as a result."	defect (bug)	reopened	normal	Future Release	Media	2.9	major