Make WordPress Core

Opened 16 years ago

Closed 16 years ago

Last modified 6 weeks ago

#11108 closed feature request (wontfix)

Hide HTML tab by default

Reported by: scribu's profile scribu Owned by:
Milestone: Priority: normal
Severity: normal Version:
Component: General Keywords: dev-feedback has-patch
Focuses: Cc:

Description

Most users shouldn't be editing raw HTML.

Take regular word processors. Does Microsoft Word or even OpenOffice have a noticeable button that allows you to edit the underlying XML of a document? That would be a nightmare.

So why should an average user see the HTML tab, by default?

The setting in the profile should allow one or the other, or both modes:

Editing modes:

[x] Visual editor
[ ] Raw HTML

Change History (14)

#1 @GamerZ
16 years ago

I disagree with this. How I wish sometimes I can edit the underlying code of MS Words because formatting it is a PITA.

#2 @sivel
16 years ago

-1 from me too. Matt Mullenweg has said in the past that depending on the type of content he is writing he will use one or the other. I do the same thing and am sure there are others who do this as well.

#3 @westi
16 years ago

  • Milestone 3.0 deleted
  • Resolution set to wontfix
  • Status changed from new to closed

-1 - This is by design and we have got to this better place by a long and wandering route.

Sometimes you do need HTML mode and sometimes not.

Closing as WONTFIX.

This ticket was mentioned in PR #11171 on WordPress/wordpress-develop by @ellatrix.


7 weeks ago
#4

  • Keywords has-patch added

## Summary

Follow-up to #11108. Makes the command palette trigger a native admin bar group element instead of a regular node in root-default, as suggested in review.

  • Registers command-palette as its own group under root using add_group(), with the trigger node inside it — this produces a sibling <ul> to root-default and top-secondary
  • Converts .quicklinks to display: flex so the three groups lay out naturally: left items, centered command palette, right items
  • Both side groups use flex: 1 1 0; min-width: fit-content — equal space when the viewport is wide (perfect centering), but they won't shrink below their content on narrow viewports
  • Command palette group uses flex: 0 0 auto between them

Existing float declarations on <li> elements become harmless (floats are ignored on flex items per CSS spec).

## Test plan

  • [ ] Load any wp-admin page: command palette button should appear centered in the admin bar
  • [ ] Click it: should open the command palette
  • [ ] Check front-end pages: button should NOT appear
  • [ ] Resize viewport — left group should push the command palette rightward rather than shrinking
  • [ ] Test RTL layout
  • [ ] Test mobile viewport (admin bar collapse behavior)
  • [ ] Test different color schemes (modern, default)

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

@westonruter commented on PR #11171:


7 weeks ago
#5

So the command palette is not accessible on mobile. Why shouldn't it be?

@ellatrix commented on PR #11171:


7 weeks ago
#6

It's the same as #11108, I don't think I changed anything there. I guess it will have to be added explicitly to the mobile version of the admin bar

@ellatrix commented on PR #11171:


7 weeks ago
#7

With several plugins installed, the search bar may become misaligned:

I think that's fine, it still looks ok?

When I open the editor, you may find the search bar overlapping, which can be a bit confusing:

What o you mean here? What overlaps what?

Personally, I think going with https://github.com/WordPress/wordpress-develop/pull/11160 might have the least impact. What do you think? cc @sabernhardt

Would need approval from design

@ocean90 commented on PR #11171:


7 weeks ago
#8

Something that looks like an input/search field but isn't one feels wrong.

When I open the editor, you may find the search bar overlapping, which can be a bit confusing:

What o you mean here? What overlaps what?

They're not overlapping, but there are two of these bars right next to each other.

@wildworks commented on PR #11171:


7 weeks ago
#9

What overlaps what?

I was referring to these two places. There are two search bars close to each other that both trigger the command palette.

https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/bd5868b5-3e72-485b-b495-874a7b7b480b

@ellatrix commented on PR #11171:


7 weeks ago
#10

@t-hamano Isn't that a problem in your PR too? How has it been addressed elsewhere? Or is there a proposal to unify them.

Something that looks like an input/search field but isn't one feels wrong.

@ocean90 It's the same for the editor document bar 🙂

@wildworks commented on PR #11171:


7 weeks ago
#11

Isn't that a problem in your PR too? How has it been addressed elsewhere?

Two approaches have been proposed that do not use a search bar in the first place.

@annezazu commented on PR #11171:


7 weeks ago
#12

Personally, I think going with https://github.com/WordPress/wordpress-develop/pull/11160 might have the least impact. What do you think?

Chatting with @mtias about this and a more condensed command‑K control is okay for beta 3 if needed, rather than the search icon. The search icon alone is not enough.

@annezazu commented on PR #11171:


6 weeks ago
#13

Let's land this ahead of the next beta so we can get more testing. Previously, the smaller command‑K control would have worked to get an initial version in to a prior beta but, at this point, it's important we stick with the design and project leadership direction.

@4thhubbard commented on PR #11171:


6 weeks ago
#14

This looks good. Please land this so we have time to test sooner rather than later.

Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.