get_the_category code duplication

[filosofo]

get_the_category needlessly duplicates the functionality of get_the_terms, and it lacks a filter that the corresponding get_the_tags has.

[scribu]

Shouldn't the filter be named 'get_the_category' ?

[filosofo]

Well, my thought was to be consistent with get_the_tags, so that the general form would be get_the_[taxonomy]s

The function itself, get_the_category(), is rather poorly named.

[scribu]

How about we deprecate get_the_category() and add a get_the_categories() then?

[filosofo]

I'll make a patch.

[filosofo]

deprecate-get_the_category.15407.diff deprecates and replaces get_the_category().

[automattor]

(In [16332]) Replace get_the_category() with get_the_categories(). Props filosofo. Fixes #15407

[nacin]

For consistency, the_category() with the_categories()?

These are very commonly used template tags so I'm not sure deprecating them for a pluralization is worth it. We've been fine for 8+ major releases with them as is.

[filosofo]

I'm not wedded to the name change, but I think the code duplication fix of the original patch should stay.

I also think that get_the_categories as a filter makes more sense than get_the_category or the like, because it's filtering an array.

[filosofo]

And actually, maybe it wouldn't be a bad idea to go with the_categories(). It's easier to remember, and the Extend theme reviewers will love having the_category() deprecated so they can smite even more themes. :)

[westi]

The name change needs to be reverted - we should and will not rename a function just for the sake of the name being more proper.

[westi]

(In [16334]) Revert most of [16332] - renaming and deprecating a commonly used function is silly. Improving it is good. Fixes #15407.

[Denis-de-Bernardy]

The newly introduced filter's name is plural and inconsistent with the function's name. Suggesting we rename it accordingly.

[filosofo]

It makes more sense to name a filter according to the use of the filter rather than its containing function, especially when the function is poorly named.

[westi]

Replying to Denis-de-Bernardy:

The newly introduced filter's name is plural and inconsistent with the function's name. Suggesting we rename it accordingly.

This is intentional.

[nacin]

(In [16343]) Move cast to within array_keys to prevent warning when get_the_terms returns false. see #15407.

[nacin]

After an IRC discussion with Viper007Bond, the issue here is that get_the_terms() may return false. I was trying to prevent issues there, but it may be cast awkwardly into an array(0=>null) which then causes some problems.

Shuffling things around here a bit.

[nacin]

(In [16395]) Properly force variable to an array. props Viper007Bond, fixes #15407.

[Viper007Bond]

Whoops, I guess you saw my message in IRC before you timed out. :)

[ryan]

(In [16487]) Populate post term relationship cache in get_the_terms(). Restores caching lost when we moved away from get_the_category(). see #15407

[gazouteast]

I struggled to follow this one - are you saying that get_the_category() and the_category() are now deprecated?

[nacin]

No. They were deprecated, then undeprecated.