Changes between Initial Version and Version 1 of Ticket #47046, comment 45
- Timestamp:
- 05/13/2019 02:34:46 PM (6 years ago)
Legend:
- Unmodified
- Added
- Removed
- Modified
-
Ticket #47046, comment 45
initial v1 3 3 We operate a maintenance service and we receive EVERYDAY questions about these arbitrary scores. The first one is the pagespeed score. People want to get 100%. They don't understand that it is not something you should wish. 4 4 5 We removed a known security plugin from our list of suggestionlist for that exact reason. We had a client that didn't get a perfect score because he didn't have 2FA... on his intranet. We had to explain that it was irrelevant.5 We removed a known security plugin from our suggestions list for that exact reason. We had a client that didn't get a perfect score because he didn't have 2FA... on his intranet. We had to explain that it was irrelevant. 6 6 7 7 I could go on forever... 8 8 9 Each time, we do not complain to Google or the concerned plugin. We simply try to educate our client and simply try to find as"as good" product that won't trigger such questions.9 Each time, we do not complain to Google or the concerned plugin. We simply try to educate our client and try to find an "as good" product that won't trigger such questions. 10 10 11 11 To me, the question becomes: is this tool for debugging or is it to give a score ? The official blog post about 5.2 states "this release adds two new pages to help debug common configuration issues." 12 12 13 As a maintenance service, we love the information it provides but we also ate anything that triggers useless support calls/emails.13 As a maintenance service, we love the information it provides but we also hate anything that triggers useless support calls/emails. 14 14 15 15 For these reasons, I still think removing the grading is the best move.