meta_input, tax_input, tags_input and post_category arguments are not available in functions or methods hooked to wp_insert_post

[henry.wright]

Functions and methods hooked to wp_insert_post are currently passed $post_ID, $post and $update. When a call to wp_insert_post() is made we can pass an array argument. The array can have meta_input, tax_input, tags_input and post_category elements.

Current call to do_action():

do_action( 'wp_insert_post', $post_ID, $post, $update );

Proposal:

do_action( 'wp_insert_post', $post_ID, $post, $update, $postarr );

Thoughts:

$postarr could be either the raw array passed to wp_insert_post() or the result of the raw array being merged with the set of defaults used.

There are more hooks in the wp_insert_post() function such as save_post. These could be updated in the same way for consistency.

[henry.wright]

This may not be feasible because I notice the wp_insert_post hook is used elsewhere and $postarr doesn't seem to be available in that context

[henry.wright]

In order to make the argument data available we may need to add a new hook. Looking at the wp_insert_post() function definition I'm struggling to find a suitable existing hook

[henry.wright]

48769.diff introduces a new hook post_inserted in wp_insert_post().

post_inserted is very much like post_updated but it will run when a post is created only. post_inserted will give hooked functions access to the $postarr array. The existing post_updated hook has been extended so that $postarr is available to hooked functions.

[SirLouen]

@henrywright what can you find in $postarr that you will not be able to pick from the post object at that point. I've been trying to check differences with some example and I cannot see a value that could make the difference

Rather than just theorizing about the utility of this change, can you put a specific use case example where you showcase a useful scenario of taking this extra parameter?

[SirLouen]

Given that this post has been stale for too long and no feedback has been received, I will preventively close it as maybelater. @henrywright if you are still experiencing this trouble or you can provide more testing information so we can proceed with this ticket, feel free to comment here, and I will be happy to reopen it and keep working on it.