Forgotten Password Error: There is no account with that username or email address when email exits

[Hube2]

I tried searching for this and came up empty. I'm surprised that no one has run into this before ne.

When an email contains "+" the email is not found and /wp-login.php?action=lostpassword return "Error: There is no account with that username or email address."

For example: {MY_EMAIL_ADDRESS}+1@{HOST}.com
This is a valid email address.
I can login with this email address, I know that this email address exists. Logged in as another user I can send a password reset and it works.
The only place this does not work is trying to reset the password on the forgotten password page.

Latest version of WP, no plugins installed, using 2024 theme.